On Remembrance Day the Governor General speaks for the people of Canada, not the monarch who lives in the United Kingdom across the sea
Nov 14th, 2026 | By Randall White | Category: In BriefRANDALL WHITE, CANADIAN REPUBLIC NOTEBOOK. TORONTO. SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2026. I watched the 2026 Remembrance Day commemoration in Ottawa this past Wednesday, November 11 on our big TV, in the comfort of my modest but agreeable house on the northwest shore of Lake Ontario.
And I was struck by the different mottoes or slogans on the wreaths laid at the national war memorial by first the governor general and then the prime minister of Canada.
(1) “The People of Canada/Le Peuple Canadien” and “The Government of Canada/Le Gouvernment du Canada”
The wreath first laid by Governor General Louise Arbour bore a blue ribbon with gold lettering which read “The People of Canada/Le Peuple Canadien”. Immediately after Prime Minister Mark Carney laid a wreath whose gold lettering on a blue ribbon read “The Government of Canada/Le Gouvernment du Canada”.
This struck me as unusually appropriate symbolism for democracy in Canada today, as somewhat surprisingly well conceived by the official national establishment in the capital city of Ottawa.
As the Toronto Star at least used to say out loud, the governor general is Canada’s “de facto head of state” — and as such the ultimate symbolic representative of the sovereign people of Canada.
Meanwhile, the prime minister (everyone who has taken even just one Canadian political science course somewhere will agree) is just the “head of government” — a practical public- policy implementing organization ultimately elected by the sovereign people.
(2) The monarchist theory still advanced by Canadian regional and national establishments and elites
This Remembrance Day wreath symbolism is somewhat surprising because on the still too much honoured official ideology almost aggressively embraced by virtually all Canadian regional and national political (and even economic) establishments, coast to coast to coast, the real or official Canadian head of state in theory is still King Charles III, who lives across the Atlantic Ocean in the old colonial mother country of the United Kingdom!
On this theory (now clearly abandoned by a democratic majority of we the Canadian masses in opinion polls) the “Governor General and Commander in Chief of Canada” is merely the local representative of King Charles. This Governor General is still theoretically appointed by the King himself in the old imperial metropolis in London (albeit since the mid 1920s on the must-be-followed advice of the Prime Minister of Canada, also accountable locally to the Governor General, and so forth round and round).
Yet if official Ottawa itself (and the offices of the governor general and prime minister) still took this old colonial ideology of the British monarchy in Canada altogether seriously, the wreath laid by the governor general at the national war memorial on Remembrance Day would read “King of Canada/Roi du Canada” — not “The People of Canada/Le Peuple Canadien”.
That “The People of Canada/Le Peuple Canadien” prevails today shows (to people like me at any rate) that even the official Ottawa establishment quietly believes we now have at least the bare beginnings of a Canadian republic as a practical matter. And we have even begun to express our “free and democratic” republicanism in our official symbolis.
(3) Different kinds of republics in Ireland, India (Iceland, Germany etc) and the USA, USA
As the experience of such former fellow British dominions as Ireland and India illustrates quite tidily, in the theoretical and practical move from constitutional monarchy to democratic republic the governor general just becomes the new head of state in theory as well as practice.
(And the office is no longer filled by prime ministerial appointment but by direct [Ireland] or indirect [India] election — representing the sovereign people. As opposed to today’s governor general whose wreaths are from the people of Canada , but who is effectively appointed by the same prime minister, who is supposed to be ultimately accountable to the same appointed Governor General (and Commander in Chief of the armed forces!), ultimately representing the same King, and/or “free and democratic” People of Canada, as on the wreaths today, etc.)

The Irish and Indian experience (just to start with, as in eg Iceland and Germany and much further beyond, etc) also puts the lie to the palpably false argument that a thorough-going free and democratic Canadian republic would have to adopt the same kind of republican constitution as the USA next door — ultimately, eg, running the risk of electing an overweening combined head of state/and/head of government like President Donald Trump in the USA today.
(Who among many other global faults also happens to be against the sovereign People of Canada. Donald Trump and others around him more than improbably but quite fundamentally believe, it seems, in Canada as some kind of 51st state of the USA, under a Governor Mark Carney, which would almost ludicrously also more than double the national geographic territory of the present United States of America.)
(4) The fundamental “constitutional position” that “has served Canada extremely well” in the new Canadian republic
As our new Mark Carney-appointed Governor General has o-so-diplomatically explained : “When asked if she is a monarchist … Louise Arbour said she thinks the constitutional position ‘has served Canada extremely well.’”

Yet in the depths of the real world the fundamental “constitutional position” here is not a monarch. It is just Canada’s separate head of state — separate from the prime ministerial head of government. And the Governor General and Commander in Chief remains our “de facto head of state” in the 2020s, even if both Justin Trudeau and Mark Carney (and perhaps even the Toronto Star?) have shown some enthusiasm for the still relatively new King Charles III, who lives in the United Kingdom across the sea (Atlantic, Pacific, and Arctic).
As quietly understood so tidily by whoever in official Ottawa decided back whenever that the Governor General’s wreath on Remembrance Day should symbolize the People of Canada/Le Peuple Canadien, inside our theoretically ongoing constitutional monarchy lie the germs of a “Westminster-style” parliamentary democratic Canadian republic.
In some ways it has already arrived. And like many other fellow Canadians today I was already happy about that, as I watched the Ottawa (and wider visiting Canadian/Canadien) elites and masses of 2026 impressively enough pay a respectful and even sometimes moving annual tribute to all who have literally and so nobly given their lives in defence of their country, and the free and democratic people of Canada who are its real ultimate sovereign power in the 21st century.




